11 May Using the course materials as a guide, identify the treatment option(s) you would deploy in a specific disaster situation, explaining your rationa
– Using the course materials as a guide, identify the treatment option(s) you would deploy in a specific disaster situation, explaining your rationale for the selection(s)
– In addition, discuss the population(s) the treatment will be used with and why this is the most appropriate choice for the population(s) identified.
350 words or more APA format
289
16 Initial Behavioral Health Response The Conundrums of a State Crisis Counseling Program
Julie L. Framingham
And.I.saw.Sisyphus.in.agonising.torment.trying.to.roll.a.huge.stone.to.the.top.of.a.hill..He. would.brace.himself,.and.push.it.towards.the.summit.with.both.hands,.but.just.as.he.was.about. to. heave. it. over. the. crest. its. weight. overcame. him,. and. then. down. again. to. the. plain. came. bounding. that. pitiless. boulder.. He. would. wrestle. again,. and. lever. it. back,. while. the. sweat. poured.from.his.limbs,.and.the.dust.swirled.round.his.head.
Bk XI: 593–640 The Odyssey
16.1 INTRODUCTION
In. the. wake. of. disaster,. state. agencies. frequently. play. a. crucial. role. in. the. immediate. response. to. impacted. communities. by. determining. if. a. need. for. behavioral. health. services. exists,. and. by. designing,.implementing,.and.managing.behavioral.health.programs..State.behavioral.health.agen- cies. have. access. to. certain. federal. funding. resources. that. are. unavailable. to. other. organizations. involved.in.disaster.response..This.chapter.will.focus.on.one.particular.federal.funding.resource,. the.Federal.Emergency.Management.Agency’s.Crisis.Counseling.Program,.and.discuss.some.of.the. challenges.encountered.in.designing,.implementing,.and.administering.the.program..In.illustration,. the.experiences.of.state.behavioral.health.agency.staff.in.Florida.as.related.to.programs.developed. around.Hurricane.Charley.and.subsequent.disasters.that.followed.from.the.period.of.2004.to.2007.
CONTENTS
16.1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 289 16.2. The.Crisis.Counseling.Program……………………………………………………………………………….. 290 16.3. Assessing.the.Need.for.Crisis.Counseling.Program.Services……………………………………….. 291 16.4. The.State.Mental.Health.Authority’s.Response.to.Hurricane.Charley…………………………… 292 16.5. Public.Misconceptions…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 293 16.6. Temporary.Disaster.Employment……………………………………………………………………………… 295 16.7. Provider.Agency.Capacity……………………………………………………………………………………….. 296 16.8. Unemployment.Compensation………………………………………………………………………………….. 296 16.9. Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 297 Notes…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 298 References……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 299
C o p y r i g h t 2 0 1 2 . C R C P r e s s .
A l l r i g h t s r e s e r v e d . M a y n o t b e r e p r o d u c e d i n a n y f o r m w i t h o u t p e r m i s s i o n f r o m t h e p u b l i s h e r , e x c e p t f a i r u s e s p e r m i t t e d u n d e r U . S . o r a p p l i c a b l e c o p y r i g h t l a w .
EBSCO Publishing : eBook Collection (EBSCOhost) – printed on 5/10/2022 3:04 PM via AMERICAN PUBLIC UNIVERSITY SYSTEM AN: 448580 ; Julie Framingham, Martell L. Teasley.; Behavioral Health Response to Disasters Account: s7348467.main.ehost
290 Behavioral Health Response to Disasters
will.be.examined.a.Therefore,.select.issues.such.as.state.agency.funding,.program.continuity,.grants. administration,.and.jurisdictional.concerns.encountered.by.program.staff.in.Florida.are.addressed,. as.well.as.some.of.the.solutions.applied..Some.of.the.challenges.described.are.not.unique.to.Florida,. however,.but.have.been.experienced.by.other.state.behavioral.health.agencies.as.well..Therefore,.it.is. hoped.that.this.chapter.will.not.only.offer.some.insight.on.the.Crisis.Counseling.Program’s.potential. obstacles,.but.encourage.other.state.behavioral.health.agencies.to.find.creative.means.to.resolve.the. potential.barriers.to.administering.future.programs.
16.2 THE CRISIS COUNSELING PROGRAM
The. Crisis. Counseling. Assistance. and. Training. Program. (CCP. or. the. Crisis. Counseling. Program).was.first.authorized.by.the.Disaster.Relief.Act.of.1974.(Pub..L..93-288),.later.amended. by.Section.416.of.the.Robert.T..Stafford.Disaster.Relief.and.Emergency.Assistance.Act.of.1988. (Stafford.Act;.Pub..L..100-707)..The.Stafford.Act.authorizes.the.president.of.the.United.States,. through. a. disaster. declaration,. to. provide. states. and. U.S.. territories. with. a. wide. array. of. pub- lic. and. individual. assistance. program. funds.. Pursuant. to. Title. 42,. Chapter. 68,. Subchapter. IV,. Section.5183:.
The.President.is.authorized.to.provide.professional.counseling.services,.including.financial.assistance. to. State. or. local. agencies. or. private. mental. health. organizations. to. provide. such. services. or. training. of.disaster.workers,.to.victims.of.major.disasters.in.order.to.relieve.mental.health.problems.caused.or. aggravated.by.such.major.disaster.or.its.aftermath.
The.CCP.is.jointly.administered.by.the.Federal.Emergency.Management.Agency.(FEMA).and. the.U.S..Department.of.Health.and.Human.Services.(HHS),.Substance.Abuse.and.Mental.Health. Services. Administration. (SAMHSA),. Center. for. Mental. Health. Services. (CMHS),. through. an. interagency.agreement.(FEMA.Crisis Counseling.nd;.SAMHSA.nd)..CMHS.provides.training. and.program.oversight,.as.well.as.monitoring.for.Regular.Services.Programs,.for.State.Mental. Health.Authorities.(SMHA;.42.U.S.C..§.201)..In.Florida,.the.SMHA.is.the.Florida.Department. of. Children. and. Families. (DCF).. DCF. has. the. responsibility. to. administer. mental. health. and. substance.abuse.services.within.the.state.and.is.eligible.to.request.grant.funding.from.FEMA.for. disaster.crisis.counseling.services.
Given.the.chronic.under-funding.of.many.state.mental.health.and.substance.abuse.services,.the. CCP.is.an.essential.resource.for.SMHAs.to.assist.large.numbers.of.survivors.experiencing.psycho- logical.distress.postdisaster..Sanctioned.CCP.activities.include.outreach,.counseling,.public.educa- tion,.and.referrals.to.community.resources..Activities.are.intended.to.assist.survivors.to.understand. their.situations.and.the.physical,.cognitive,.and.behavioral.reactions.that.can.result,.including.anxi- ety,. fear,. anger,. grief,. hopelessness,. and. changes. in. sleep. patterns. or. appetite.. Crisis. counselors,. sometimes. called. outreach. workers,. attempt. to. alleviate. adverse. stress. reactions. in. survivors. by. providing.emotional.support..Using.active.listening,.they.help.validate.the.survivors’.reactions.and. assist. them. to. understand. that. they. are. reacting. normally. to. an. abnormal. event. (SAMHSA. CCP. Program.Guidance.nd)..Psychoeducation.is.a.key.component.of.the.CCP.and.has.been.demonstrated. to. be. effective. in. a. number. of. trauma. contexts.. Psychoeducation. can. assist. individuals,. families,. and.communities.by.normalizing.stress.reactions.and.ameliorating.distress,.and.encourage.support. seeking,. resilience,. and. community. cooperation. (Layne. et. al.. 2008;. Jacobs,. Vernberg,. and. Lee. 2008;.Marbley.2007;.Naturale.2007;.Fremont.2004;.AACAP.2007)..
Crisis. counselors. also. help. survivors. review. their. recovery. options. and. teach. coping. skills. and. relaxation. techniques,. among. other. nonclinical. interventions.. Crisis. counseling. activities. are. short. term. and. community. based. and. occur. at. survivors’. homes,. schools,. places. of. employment,. senior. centers,. and. community. centers,. among. other. sites. (SAMHSA. CCP. Program. Guidance. nd)..Research.suggests.that.community.outreach.may.be.especially.helpful.for.reaching.out.to.and.
EBSCOhost – printed on 5/10/2022 3:04 PM via AMERICAN PUBLIC UNIVERSITY SYSTEM. All use subject to https://www.ebsco.com/terms-of-use
291Initial Behavioral Health Response
empowering.certain.vulnerable.groups.after.disaster..These.groups.include.ethnic.minorities,.older. adults,. individuals. with. mental. illness,. or. others. who. lack. social. support. systems. and. services,. especially. when. delivered. by. indigenous,. trained. workers. (Norris. and. Alegria. 2005;. Elmore. and. Brown.2007;.Person.and.Fuller.2007;.Hardiman.and.Jaffee.2008)..Further,.communications.with. diverse.populations.in.the.community.assist.outreach.workers.to.overcome.biases.and.become.more. culturally.aware.(Goodman.and.West-Olatunji.2009)..CMHS.expects.SMHAs.to.develop.CCPs.that. acknowledge.the.diversity.of.the.communities.served.by.targeting.ethnic.and.racial.minorities.and. hiring. indigenous. workers. who. reflect. the. community’s. demographic. makeup. whenever. possible. (SAMHSA.CCP.Program.Guidance.nd).
16.3 ASSESSING THE NEED FOR CRISIS COUNSELING PROGRAM SERVICES
Two.funding.mechanisms.are.available.to.SMHAs.through.the.CCP:.(1). the.Immediate.Services. Program,.which.provides.up.to.60.days.of.funding.for.disaster.crisis.counseling.services,.and.(2).the. Regular.Services.Program,.which.provides.for.an.additional.nine.months.of.funding.(FEMA Crisis Counseling.nd;.SAMHSA.nd)..The.date.of.the.presidential.disaster.declaration.is.the.start.date.for. both. the. Immediate. Services. Program. and. Regular. Services. Program. (SAMHSA. CCP. Program. Guidance.nd)..Between.2004.and.2007,.Florida’s.Immediate.Services.Program.grant.applications. were.approved.quickly,.whereas.Regular.Services.Program.grant.applications.averaged.between.8. and.22.weeks.for.review.and.approval.(Kimber.2007)..Requests.for.no-cost.extensions.(to.extend.the. program.end.date.without.additional.funding).or.additional-cost.extensions.of.Immediate.Services. Programs.were.therefore.necessary.to.avoid.services.disruption.
Given.the.copious.amount.of.information.that.needs.to.be.included.in.the.grant.applications,. this.generally.means.weeks.to.months.of.extended.workdays.for.SMHA.staff.assessing.the.needs. of.the.affected.communities,.gathering.the.data,.and.developing.the.plan.of.services.and.the.bud- get..CMHS.requires.SMHAs.to.complete.the.CMHS.Needs.Assessment.Formula.for.Estimating. Disaster. Mental. Health. Needs. (CMHS. Needs. Assessment;. included. in. the. grant. applications). when.calculating.the.numbers.of.survivors.who.might.benefit.from.crisis.counseling..The.CMHS. Needs.Assessment.follows.the.FEMA.damage.assessment.concept.and.includes.loss.categories. of.numbers.of.dead,.hospitalized,.or.otherwise.reported.injured;.homes.with.minor.and.major. damages,. or. totally. destroyed;. and. numbers. of. survivors. who. became. unemployed. as. a. result. of. the. disaster.. Each. CCP. grant. application. was. developed. in. close. consultation. with. FEMA. and.CMHS.project.officers.because.FEMA.damage.assessments.were.not.always.completed.for. each. county,. or. they. were. completed. under. very. difficult. conditions,. making. it. impossible. to. obtain.more.than.a.superficial.estimate.of.damages..FEMA.Individual.Assistance.applications. for.each.county.are.also.helpful.data.for.assessing.crisis.counseling.needs,.but.CMHS.discour- aged.use.of.these.data.if.using.the.FEMA.damage.assessment.methodology.due.to.the.potential. for.duplication.
Consequently,.DCF.program.staff.had.to.be.resourceful.to.find.ways.to.include.other.loss.cat- egories.or.data.sources.in.the.formula.that.would.be.acceptable.to.CMHS.and.FEMA.in.order.to. provide.more.realistic.numbers.of.individuals.likely.to.benefit.from.crisis.counseling..Negotiation. was.also.necessary.since.the.numbers.of.teams.and.team.members,.as.well.as.ratios.of.crisis.coun- selors.to.team.leaders,.were.prescribed.based.on.the.numbers.of.survivors.calculated.to.benefit.from. services.in.the.CMHS.Needs.Assessment..With.each.grant.application,.DCF.presented.the.unique. aspects.of.the.impacted.counties.and.the.service.districts.responding.to.the.disaster.by.highlighting. conditions.that.made.the.use.of.standardized.staffing.formulas.problematic..For.instance,.are.the. impacted.counties.mostly.urban.or.rural?.In.the.latter.case,.teams.may.have.to.travel.much.greater. distances.to.reach.survivors..Population.density.or.large.cultural.groups.could.also.be.reasonable. grounds.to.deviate.from.expected.staffing.formulas..While.the.state.may.include.special.populations. or.other.circumstances.in.other.sections.of.the.grant.application,.the.CMHS.Needs.Assessment is. given.significant.weight.during.the.application.review.
EBSCOhost – printed on 5/10/2022 3:04 PM via AMERICAN PUBLIC UNIVERSITY SYSTEM. All use subject to https://www.ebsco.com/terms-of-use
292 Behavioral Health Response to Disasters
16.4 THE STATE MENTAL HEALTH AUTHORITY’S RESPONSE TO HURRICANE CHARLEY
In.the.days.leading.up.to.the.landfall.of.Hurricane.Charley.in.August.2004,.personnel.in.the.Mental. Health.Program.Office.at.DCF.were.busy.preparing.for.the.storm’s.arrival..The.National.Hurricane. Center’s.tracking.and.prediction.graphic.models.suggested.that.the.hurricane.would.strike.Florida’s. Gulf.Coast.somewhere.between.the.Fort.Myers.and.the.Tampa.Bay.areas.with.initial.reports.pre- dicting.the.latter.being.the.most.likely.point.of.landfall.(NOAA.2006)..In.anticipation.of.Hurricane. Charley’s.arrival,.then.Governor.Jeb.Bush.executed.Executive.Order.#04-182.on.August.11.declar- ing.a.State.of.Emergency.(SLAF.nd).
On.Friday,.August.13,.2004,.Hurricane.Charley,.with.little.warning,.turned.suddenly.from. its.greatly.anticipated.landfall.near.Tampa.Bay.and.slammed.into.the.southwest.coast.of.Florida. at. Captiva. Island,. and. then. Port. Charlotte,. as. a. Category. 4. storm. with. winds. approaching. 150 mph.(NOAA.2006)..It.was.the.strongest.hurricane.to.hit.the.United.States.since.Hurricane. Andrew. in. 1992. (FDEP. nd).. It. was. also. the. first. time. Florida. had. been. struck. by. two. major. storms. in. less. than. 36. hours. (Tropical. Storm. Bonnie. struck. northwest. Florida. on. August. 12;. Avila. 2004;. FDEP. nd).. The. storm. then. continued. diagonally,. north. by. northeast,. across. the. state,.before.exiting.near.Daytona.Beach.as.a.Category.2.hurricane..Almost.1.5.million.people. evacuated. their. homes.. Tens. of. thousands. of. homes. and. businesses. were. damaged. or. totally. destroyed. and. more. than. 2. million. residents. were. left. without. electricity.. Damages. exceeded. $11. billion.. There. were. 24. hurricane-related. deaths. and. 792. injuries. (NOAA. nd).. Due. to. the. enormity.of.the.disaster,.Governor.Bush.requested.federal.assistance.from.the.president,.who. issued.a.Federal.Disaster.Declaration,.FEMA-1539,.the.same.day.(FEMA.Major Disaster.nd).. Of. Florida’s. 67. counties,. 26. were. declared. disaster. areas. eligible. for. Individual. Assistance. funding,.including.the.CCP.
It.had.been.several.years.since.the.state.of.Florida.had.experienced.a.major.disaster.or.had.the. need. to. provide. crisis. counseling. for. survivors. trying. to. cope. with. the. emotional. aftermath. of. a. storm..Nevertheless,.anticipating.there.would.be.a.need.for.such.a.response.to.Hurricane.Charley,. the. Disaster. Behavioral. Health. Coordinator. and. other. key. DCF. leaders. began. discussions. about. how.to.prepare.a.response.ahead.of.the.storm’s.arrival..They.formed.a.small.team.of.workers.con- sisting.of.several.permanent.and.temporary.staff b.to.develop.the.response.
Fortunately,. there. were. a. few. team. members. who. had. developed. CCP. grant. applications. for. prior. disasters.. DCF. was. also. contacted. by. federal. project. officers. with. offers. of. guidance. for. developing. the. grant. application.. The. Disaster. Behavioral. Health. Coordinatorc. had. been. making. preparations. throughout. the. preceding. year. by. obtaining. support. from. the. department’s. senior. management. should. the. need. arise. to. provide. a. behavioral. health. response. to. a. disaster.. He. also. cultivated.useful.contacts.at.other.state.agencies.and.nonprofit.organizations.that.could.offer.assis- tance.during.or.postdisaster,.including.the.Florida.Department.of.Health,.the.Department.of.Elder. Affairs,.the.State.Emergency.Operations.Center,.the.National.Organization.for.Victim.Assistance. (NOVA),.and.Florida.Interfaith.Networking.in.Disasters.(FIND)..FIND.played.a.prominent.role.in. the.Department’s.response.as.this.organization.was.able.to.put.the.DCF.in.contact.with.Lutheran. Disaster.Response.and.other.helpful.nongovernmental.organizations..Lutheran.Disaster.Response. offered.to.host.daily.conference.calls.for.Florida’s.state.agencies.and.voluntary.organizations.to.help. the.state.provide.an.adequate.level.of.coverage.for.behavioral.health.services.in.the.impacted.com- munities.while.avoiding.duplication..These.calls.helped.establish.lasting.collaborative.partnerships. by.fostering.candid.discussion.and.the.sharing.of.information.and.resources.among.the.participating. agencies.
Before.Hurricane.Charley,.DCF.endeavored.to.increase.its.capacity.to.respond.to.disasters.by. developing.and.training.a.volunteer.cadre..Long.experience.had.made.DCF’s.leadership.realize. that.each.time.a.disaster.was.over.and.the.impacted.communities.had.returned.to.“normal,”.the. staff.who.had.gained.experience.working.in.the.disaster.drifted.away.for.various.reasons..New.
EBSCOhost – printed on 5/10/2022 3:04 PM via AMERICAN PUBLIC UNIVERSITY SYSTEM. All use subject to https://www.ebsco.com/terms-of-use
293Initial Behavioral Health Response
employment. opportunities,. relocation,. burnout,. or. disillusionment. after. prior. disaster. work,. or. lack.of.supervisory.support,.were.recurring.grounds.for.later.nonparticipation.and.contributed.to. a.chronic.loss.of.institutional.memory..The.agency.was.also.hamstrung.by.the.fact.that.disaster. behavioral. health. preparedness. funding. from. the. Centers. for. Disease. Control. and. Prevention. (CDC).and.the.Office.of.the.Assistant.Secretary.for.Preparedness.and.Response.(ASPR).is.ear- marked.for.ESF.8,.Public.Health.and.Medical,.agencies..Under.the.National.Response.Framework,d. ESF.8.agencies.are.tasked.to.provide.disaster.behavioral.health.services.e.In.Florida,.however,.the. ESF.8.agency.is.the.Department.of.Health,.whereas.DCF.is.designated.as.an.ESF.6,.Mass.Care,. agency..ESF.6.agencies.are.responsible.for.providing.disaster.crisis.counseling.(Sundararaman,. Lister,.and.Williams.2006).f
Without. preparedness. funding,. DCF. did. not. have. the. resources. to. maintain. sufficient. staff. year-round.to.prepare.for.future.disasters.and.sustain.its.knowledge.base..The.sustainment.prob- lem.was.not,.however,.limited.to.headquarters.staff..It.was.common.throughout.the.DCF.system,. including.its.contracted.community.agencies..Thus,.when.Hurricane.Charley.arrived,.DCF.found. itself.in.the.same.predicament.as.before..In.fact,.the.department.was.to.reexperience.this.same. dilemma.and.others.with.each.succeeding.hurricane.as.Hurricane.Charley.was.quickly.followed. by.Hurricanes.Jeanne,.Francis,.and.Ivan.in.2004,.and.Hurricanes.Dennis,.Wilma,.and.Katrinag. in.2005.
DCF.distributed.its.disaster.cadre.at.Disaster.Recovery.Centers,h.DCF.emergency.food.stamp. locations,i.comfort.stations,.or.other.designated.sites.established.within.the.impacted.areas..The. cadre.and.DCF’s.disaster.partners.provided.immediate.assistance.for.survivors.and.freed.SMHA. staff.to.develop.the.grant.applications.to.secure.sufficient.federal.funding.for.recovery.services.. Cadre. members. brought. educational. materials. and. set. up. information. tables. within. the. sites.. They.provided.emotional.support,.listened.to.the.survivors’.disaster.experiences,.provided.them. with. guidance. in. completing. FEMA. or. other. applications. for. assistance,. and. steered. them. to. helping.resources..One.colleague.described.her.first.experience.as.a.crisis.counselor.in.a.Disaster. Recovery.Center..She.stated.a.male.survivor.approached.her.while.she.was.standing.at.her.infor- mation.table:
She.asked,.“How.may.I.help.you.sir?”.The.man.immediately.exploded.into.a.tirade.concerning.his.frus- trations.with.the.disaster,.the.response.process,.and.the.bureaucratic.“red.tape”.that.impeded.obtaining. the.assistance.that.he.desperately.needed..The.crisis.counselor’s.eyes.opened.wide.and.she.froze.in.fear.. After.a.couple.of.minutes,.however,.she.plucked.up.her.nerve.and.repeated.her.question.
“Sir,.how.can.I.help.you?”
Suddenly,.the.survivor.ceased.his.tirade,.took.a.deep.breath.and.looked.at.her.and.said,.“I.feel.much. better.now..Thank.you!”.He.then.walked.off.without.asking.for.any.other.assistance.or.information.j
The. point. illustrated. here. is. that. crisis. counselors. provide. a. great. deal. of. emotional. support. simply.by.listening.to.survivors’.stories..Survivors.may.not.need.much.more.than.having.someone. listen.to.them.and/or.some.informational.materials.to.help.them.understand.their.reactions.to.the. disaster.and.learn.more.adaptive.ways.to.cope.with.current.stressors.
16.5 PUBLIC MISCONCEPTIONS
In. fact,. the. term. crisis counseling. is. somewhat. misleading. since. all. CCP. services,. even. when. delivered.by.licensed.behavioral.health.specialists,.are.nonclinical.in.nature..However,.the.disaster. literature.suggests.that.the.majority.of.survivors.do.not.develop.long-term.posttraumatic.psychopa- thology.(Gray,.Litz,.and.Maguen.2004;.Davidson.and.McFarlane.2006),.especially.in.the.absence. of. extensive. property. damage,. injuries. and. loss. of. life,. or. human-caused. incidents. (Norris. et. al.. 2001)..Consequently,.no.clinical.services.are.authorized.under.the.CCP.(SAMHSA.CCP.Program.
EBSCOhost – printed on 5/10/2022 3:04 PM via AMERICAN PUBLIC UNIVERSITY SYSTEM. All use subject to https://www.ebsco.com/terms-of-use
294 Behavioral Health Response to Disasters
Guidance.nd)..Crisis.counselors.are.expected.to.refer.individuals.in.need.of.clinical.mental.health.or. substance.abuse.treatment.to.preexisting.community.behavioral.health.agencies,.which.frequently. have. long. waiting. lists. for. Medicaid-funded. services.. An. unfortunate. consequence. of. failing. to. authorize.clinical.services.is.that,.of.those.individuals.who.do.go.on.to.develop.long-term.psycho- logical.or.substance.use.disorders,.the.uninsured.and.under-insured.suffer.the.most.(Sundararaman,. Lister,.and.Williams.2006).
The.fact.that.no.clinical.services.are.offered.in.the.CCP.appears.to.contradict.the.Stafford.Act’s. language,.which.states.that.“professional.counseling”.may.be.offered.to.survivors.experiencing. psychological.distress.postdisaster.(42.U.S.C..§.5183)..However,.it.has.been.left.up.to.CMHS.to. determine.what.constitutes.professional.counseling.(Drury,.Scheeringa,.and.Zeanah.2008)..The. FEMA. CCP. instead. relies. on. many. of. the. same. principles. used. in. the. Psychological. First. Aid. model. developed. by. the. National. Child. Traumatic. Stress. Network. (NCTSN). and. the. National. Center. for. Posttraumatic. Stress. Disorder. (NCPTSD),. which. many. organizations. have. endorsed. as. a. preferred. intervention. for. response. to. emergencies. or. disasters. (Chapter. 10,. this. volume).. Similar.to.the.CCP,.Psychological.First.Aid.is.used.in.diverse.community.settings.and.is.designed. to.provide.disaster.survivors.with.nonclinical.assistance..Core.components.of.Psychological.First. Aid. involve. engaging,. comforting,. and. stabilizing. survivors;. gathering. information. about. their. needs. or. concerns. and. offering. practical. help. to. satisfy. those. needs;. connecting. survivors. to. social.support.systems.and.community.resources;.and.providing.information.on.stress.reactions. and.coping.(Brymer.et.al..2006).
Misconceptions.about.what.the.CCP.has.to.offer.survivors.has.led.to.a.number.of.misunderstand- ings. with. the. media. and,. consequently,. with. the. public.. This. has. at. times. occurred. with. painful. results,. not. just. for. Florida’s. DCF,. but. also. for. other. SMHAs. that. have. implemented. CCPs.. The. media. have. sometimes. assumed. that. crisis. counseling. refers. to. clinical. counseling,. and. various. news.stories.have.criticized.CCPs.for.failing.to.provide.clinical.services..For.example,.in.October. 2006,.the.New Orleans Times-Picayune.published.a.news.story.(Varney.2006).about.the.SMHA’s. Louisiana.Spiritk.wherein.it.criticized.FEMA.for.not.allowing.CCP.funding.to.be.spent.on.“medical. doctors”.and.instead.implied.it.was.being.spent.on.“muffins.and.coffee.”.The.article.further.stated. that. research. concerning. the. CCP’s. effectiveness. is. lacking. and. an. expert. source. was. quoted. as. suggesting.that.the.program.possibly.causes.more.harm.than.good.(Varney.2006)..The.fact.that.the. trauma. expert. cited. in. the. story. referred. to. the. CCP’s. intervention. as. “psychological. debriefing”l. suggests.he.was.unaware.that.the.CCP.does.not.permit.use.of.psychological.debriefing.(SAMHSA. CCP.Program.Guidance.nd,.14),.which.indeed.has.come.under.fire.as.a.means.of.assisting.disaster. survivors.and.has.been.discouraged.from.practice.by.some.researchers.(Rose.et al..1999;.Mayou,. Ehlers,.and.Hobbs.2000;.Rose.et.al..2001;.Litz.et.al..2002;.NIMH.2002)..
It.is.true,.however,.that.there.have.been.few.studies.of.the.CCP.that.sought.to.examine.the. program’s.effectiveness.(Elrod,.Hamblen,.and.Norris.2006;.Norris,.Hamblen,.and.Rosen.2009;. Drury,. Scheeringa,. and. Zeanah. 2008).. Evaluating. the. CCP’s. effectiveness. has. been. difficult. because,.unlike.clients.in.traditional.mental.health.systems,.crisis.counseling.services.are.short. term.(CMHS.recommends.assessment.and.referral.after.three.visits;.SAMHSA.CCP.Program. Guidance. nd,. 19). and. no. personally. identifying. information. is. retained.. Therefore,. it. is. not. possible. to. obtain. pre-. and. posttest. measures. of. the. program’s. efficacy. in. ameliorating. post- disaster.distress.(Norris,.Hamblen,.and.Rosen.2009;.Drury,.Scheeringa,.and.Zeanah.2008)..It. is.also.true.that.FEMA.and.CMHS.have.allowed.SMHAs.wide.latitude.in.administering.CCPs.. CCPs.use.a.wide.variety.of.outreach.and.engagement.strategies.to.identify.survivors.who.might. benefit. from. services.. In. October. 2006,. Florida’s. Hurricane. Wilma. and. Hurricane. Katrina. Regular.Services.Programs.were.criticized.by.the.Fort.Lauderdale.Sun-Sentinel.(Kestin.2006a). as.a.ridiculous.waste.of.taxpayer.money.because.of.the.staff.time.expended.on.what.the.paper. alleged.to.be.frivolous,.ineffective.strategies.to.identify.and.engage.survivors..These.strategies. included. dressing. in. costume. and. singing. songs. for. preschoolers.. The. news. story. featured. a. performance.by.crisis.counselors.dressed.in.costumes.at.a.preschool.where.they.sang,.“Windy.
EBSCOhost – printed on 5/10/2022 3:04 PM via AMERICAN PUBLIC UNIVERSITY SYSTEM. All use subject to https://www.ebsco.com/terms-of-use
295Initial Behavioral Health Response
Biggie.is.our.friend..Windy.Biggie.is.strong.wind..She.turns,.turns,.turns,.turns.around..She’s. knocking.things.to.the.ground.”
The. story. also. discussed. how. CCP. funds. were. expended. on. staff. organizing. hurricane. bingo,. puppet.shows,.and.yoga.for.various.organizations.as.a.way.to.try.to.identify.and.reach.out.to.sur- vivors..The.crisis.counselors.interviewed.admitted.that.finding.survivors.who.might.really.benefit. from. the. CCP. was. difficult. because,. despite. the. fact. that. the. program. is. FEMA. funded,. FEMA. would.not.share.the.names.and.addresses.of.FEMA.aid.registrants.due.to.privacy.concerns.(Kestin. 2006a)..This.was.not.always.the.case,.however,.but.transpired.after.FEMA.instituted.a.policy.change. in.the.late.1990s.due.to.privacy.concerns.(Elrod,.Hamblen,.and.Norris.2006).
Following. the. Sun-Sentinel’s. report,. The. Honorable. Susan. M.. Collins,. Chairman. of. the. Committee. on. Homeland. Security. and. Governmental. Affairs,. requested. both. FEMA. and. HHS. to. investigate. Project. H.O.P.E.’s. Hurricane. Wilma. and. Katrina. programs. to. determine. if. federal. funding.was.being.wasted.(Department.of.Homeland.Security.2008).m.The.Sun-Sentinel.continued. publishing. articles. critical. of. Florida’s. CCPs. over. the. next. few. months.. In. December. 2006,. the. newspaper.reported.CCPs.administered.in.states.other.than.Florida.had.also.engaged.in.allegedly. inappropriate. activities. (Kestin. 2006b).. The. article. referred. to. other. CCPs. (California,. Virginia,. Wisconsin,.and.Colorado).offering.classes.on.crafts,.martial.arts,.canning.and.freezing.foods,.pro- viding. massages,. haircuts,. and. gumbo. cook-offs,. among. other. engagement. strategies,. to. identify. survivors. and. offer. crisis. counseling. services. (Kestin. 2006b).. Later,. in. January. 2007,. the. Sun- Sentinel. (Kestin. 2007). reported. that. Rep.. Tom. Feeney,. R-Oviedo,. and. Rep.. Mario. Diaz-Balart,. R-Miami,.intended.to.file.a.bill.to.prevent.future.federal.disaster.funding.from.being.spent.on.crisis. counseling.activities.ensuring.that.“no.disaster.relief.funds.are.used.for.any.type.of.crisis.counsel- ing,.recreation.or.self-esteem.building.classes.or.instruction,.including.but.not.limited.to.dance.and. exercise.classes,.bingo,.gardening.workshops,.puppet.shows.or.theater.productions.”.FEMA’s.initial. response.to.Sen..Collins.in.December.2008.found.that.Project.H.O.P.E..was.spending.its.funding.on. “reasonable.and.approved.items.and.activities”.under.federal.guidelines.(Kestin.2007;.Department. of.Homeland.Security.2008)..FEMA’s.final.report.of.its.findings.was.not.released.until.September. 2008.(Department.of.Homeland.Security.2008)..Suffice.it.to.say.that.there.is.a.genuine.need.to.cre- ate.a.more.realistic.public.perception.of.crisis.counseling.
16.6 TEMPORARY DISASTER EMPLOYMENT
From. 2004. to. 2007,. DCF. had. to. overcome. many. challenges. to. the. program,. and. the. unfavor- able.media.coverage.of.the.Fort.Lauderdale.Sun-Sentinel.was.just.one.head.of.the.hydra..Other. barriers. to. the. CCP. included. the. use. of. temporary. disaster. workers. and. unemployment. com- pensation.issues..Until.2006,.DCF.used.two.options.for.hiring.disaster.teams:.the.teams.were. either.contracted.through.community.behavioral.health.agencies,.or.they.were.hired.directly.as. temporary.departmental.staff.by.the.service.districts.in.the.impacted.areas..Contracting.through. a. community. agency. meant. the. workers. could. receive. certain. fringe. benefits. that. temporary. departmental. disaster. staff. members. were. not. given.. No. line. item. expenses. for. vacation. or. sick.leave,.pension.or.unemployment.benefits.were.included.in.the.CCP.budgets.for.temporary. departmental workers.
The.decision.to.hire.teams.as.temporary.departmental.staff.or.on.contract.was.left.up.to.indi- vidual. DCF. service. district. managers.. Some. of. the. service. districts. elected. to. hire. CCP. teams. directly.rather.than.contract.them.out.to.community.behavioral.health.agencies..A.disadvantage. to.this.hiring.method.was.that.the.district.supervisors.were.then.responsible.for.supervising.many. more.staff,.which.could.be.quite.challeng
Our website has a team of professional writers who can help you write any of your homework. They will write your papers from scratch. We also have a team of editors just to make sure all papers are of HIGH QUALITY & PLAGIARISM FREE. To make an Order you only need to click Ask A Question and we will direct you to our Order Page at WriteDemy. Then fill Our Order Form with all your assignment instructions. Select your deadline and pay for your paper. You will get it few hours before your set deadline.
Fill in all the assignment paper details that are required in the order form with the standard information being the page count, deadline, academic level and type of paper. It is advisable to have this information at hand so that you can quickly fill in the necessary information needed in the form for the essay writer to be immediately assigned to your writing project. Make payment for the custom essay order to enable us to assign a suitable writer to your order. Payments are made through Paypal on a secured billing page. Finally, sit back and relax.
About Wridemy
We are a professional paper writing website. If you have searched a question and bumped into our website just know you are in the right place to get help in your coursework. We offer HIGH QUALITY & PLAGIARISM FREE Papers.
How It Works
To make an Order you only need to click on “Order Now” and we will direct you to our Order Page. Fill Our Order Form with all your assignment instructions. Select your deadline and pay for your paper. You will get it few hours before your set deadline.
Are there Discounts?
All new clients are eligible for 20% off in their first Order. Our payment method is safe and secure.