06 Jul Why are there ‘natural disasters’ (ex. storms, earthquakes, plagues)? Do you agree or disagree with Clough’s explanation in the Module 1: Week 1 reading over evil in man and nature?
Why are there "natural disasters" (ex. storms, earthquakes, plagues)? Do you agree or disagree with Clough's explanation in the Module 1: Week 1 reading over evil in man and nature? Explain your reasons.
The explanations are attached.
CJUS 381
Discussion Assignment Instructions
There are 3 Discussions in this course. You will post an initial thread by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Thursday of the assigned Module: Week. You will then post 2 replies to other students’ post by 11:59 p.m. (ET) on Monday of the assigned Module: Week. Initial post must have 100-200 words, while replies must have 50-100 words. There is no word or citation requirement for any posting, but each post must add substantively to the conversation. Only post plain text content. Do not include formatted elements if pasting content from a word processor. If referencing outside sources of information, include URL links to the source if available.
,
WHAT IS MAN? Let's begin with man first. The Bible and pagan culture radically disagree on what
man is. To see just how radical the disagreement is, I will begin with a look at the biblical narratives
of man's creation. Then I will show how man's design utterly sets him apart from all the universe.
Finally, I will introduce the concept of "divine institutions"–the fundamental features of human social
existence according to God's Word. God's Description of Man's Creation The "close-up" picture of
man's creation is given in Genesis 2:7,15-25. God says He miraculously formed man from the earth.
The term "dust" in this context is sometimes interpreted by those following an accommodationist
strategy as metaphorical for man's upward development from primates. They think by so doing they
can accommodate the Genesis narrative to the evolutionary worldview. Unfortunately for this
approach, the term "dust" in Lesson 10 Page 34
_______________________________________________________________ Part II Bible Framework Ministries
www.bibleframework.org this context is used for literal earth particles of bodily decay after death
(Gen. 3:19). Clearly, at death man does not revert back to his supposedly previous primate existence!
The narrative, therefore, speaks of a literal, instantaneous creation of man. If the narrative's literal
meaning weren't clear enough from 2:7, it certainly is from 2:21-22. Unlike any other species, the
human female is derived from the one original body. This is not an incidental detail; it relates to the
entire plan of salvation as I note later. There is simply no room in this narrative for evolution of man
from primate. This literal interpretation of Genesis 2 is given in the New Testament (I Cor. 11:6-9; I
Tim.2:13-14). Also note that man is assigned to a task that involves labor and moral responsibility
(2:15-17). Such a task requires social intercourse with other human beings (2:18). Accomplishment
of the task involves study of nature and linguistic description (2:19-20). The other narrative of man's
creation (Gen. 1:26-30) reports that mankind as male and female is made in God's image. In the
ancient world kings would set up images of themselves down among the people for them to worship
(see Dan. 3). The images were their glory. Here God sets up an image of himself down at the
creature level of existence, not to be worshipped, but to be respected for His glory (Jas. 3:9). This
image of God is to rule God's earth by subduing it and filling it by procreation. God put into these
narratives observational data that have immense significance. We are uniquely designed for a
glorious role in the history of the universe. Let's look at some key features in man's design
WHAT IS NATURE? I have shown the human side of the man-nature distinction; now I turn to the
nature side. By "nature" I include all of creation that is not man–rocks, water, plants, animals, angels,
and stars. The first lesson taught to the first man was that nothing in nature fits his need for a
personal relationship (Gen. 2:18-20). In his present mortal state man is temporarily lower than the
angels and is confined in some way to the local part of nature which we now call planet earth (Psa.
8:3-8). It is with this local part of nature that I will devote most of our attention. I will begin with a
look at the overall design of nature in distinction from the design of man. Then I will deal with man's
relationship with nature through the exercise of his dominion. I will show you four very significant
universal limitations on this dominion that doom all carnal dreams of rebellion against God. Design
of Nature Old writers of centuries ago used to refer to nature as "dumb" and "brute" to distinguish its
essential character from that of man. These writers did not use the word "dumb" like we do today, as
a synonym for "stupid". "Dumb" used to refer to the inability to speak thoughts through language, i.e.,
speechlessness. "Brute" meant without ability to know. These writers, we shall see, were nearer to
the truth than they knew. Whereas Adam could not find a speech-laden, personal relationship with
any part of nature, he could and did receive revelation about God from nature. Natural (or general)
revelation is spoken of everywhere in the Bible (e.g., Job 38-41; Psa. 19:1-6; Acts 14:17; Rom. 1:18-
20). The creation is said to "glorify" its Creator. But if nature doesn't personally speak to us, if it is
"dumb", then how can we learn about God from it? How, without language, Part II
__________________________________________________________________ Page 43 Bible Framework
Ministries www.bibleframework.org can information be transferred from nature to our minds? How
does nature "glorify" God? Nature contains patterns and forms that we recognize as products of a
thinking, speaking, spirit-mind, similar to our own. It is precisely the meaning of these patterns and
forms that modern paganism (in its evolutionary form) denies by ascribing them to chance. Pilkey
notes: "The whole point of the Creationist-Darwinian debate is whether the leonine form, for
example, originated as a perfect idea in the mind of God or as a casual exercise in feline
development. . . .The evolutionary philosophy begins to lose its appeal the instant that a mind begins
to suspect that certain visible forms have eternal value.[8] The form and behavior of a lamb, for
example, instead of being the accidental outcome of chance-driven mutations and natural selection,
was purposefully designed to communicate redemptive knowledge to man (note its appearance on
the Throne of God in Rev. 5). Nature, while not originating its own thoughts in speech to us as
another person would, is loaded with information from God's thoughts. You can see and recognize
this information not only in heavenly patterns (Psa. 19:1-6) and in large-scale animal forms (Job 38-
41), but in what has been recently learned about the biological cell and its genetic codes. Note here
that I am claiming not merely that forms exist, but that we also recognize that the forms carry a
message. To show the difference between merely saying a pattern is observed and saying the
pattern carries meaningful information to our minds, I adapt an illustration from A. E. Wilder-Smith.
Imagine looking at a series of apparently random dots and dashes arranged in a sequence. As your
eye looks along the sequence, you notice a pattern (. . . _ _ _ . . .). If you are knowledgeable of Morse
Code, you immediately see the pattern as containing a message, "S.O.S.", the international sign for
help. If you are not knowledgeable of the Morse Code "language", you merely notice an interesting
pattern but do not see any message in it. To "get the message" or for the pattern to be meaningful,
you and the originator of the pattern must share a common language.[9] In much the same way
nature is filled with forms and patterns noticed by all men everywhere. The Bible insists that such
patterns actually are carrying meaningful messages about the Creator. They contain information
about His character, that He plans and purposes. They "glorify Him" and "show His handiwork". We
"get the message" because the patterns resemble objects we make and think about with our
personal spirits acting through our bodies. Our spirits recognize the Presence of Another Spirit Who
thinks informationfilled thoughts. Page 44
_______________________________________________________________ Part II Bible Framework Ministries
www.bibleframework.org Notice I said, natural patterns "resemble" patterns of man-made objects,
not that they are identical. Unbelievers often try to oppose the so-called teleological argument for
God (argument from design) by citing instances of chaos or apparently useless features. But the
Bible doesn't teach that every part of nature can be "read" correctly. Much of nature has been
irreversibly damaged by the fall (see Chapter Four). Even some of the parts that weren't ruined by the
fall in original Eden, had to be explained directly to Adam using spoken words (Gen 1:28-30; 2:16-17).
So nature doesn't always carry a clearly understandable message, but it does carry significant
amounts of information about its Maker from His Spirit to our spirits.[10] Just because the design of
nature does glorify God, the carnal mind must somehow falsify it. The information that natural
designs convey about their Creator must be shut off. The easiest way to bury this information can be
inferred from Wilder-Smith's Morse Code illustration above. By denying (or suppressing or
forgetting) the Morse Code language rules, the "S-O-S" pattern loses all meaning. In like fashion, by
suppressing the human spirit's sense of eternity (Eccl. 3:11) and the personal God of eternity,
paganism shuts off reception of the information coming to it from nature (Rom. 1:21). However,
paganism can never leave matters alone. The suppressed yearning of the human spirit for God can't
stand total meaninglessness. Thus it redirects itself and fabricates meaning for all the natural
design it observes (Rom. 1:22). It exchanges the information about God attached to natural design
for pseudo-information that man's mind makes up and imposes on the forms and patterns (Rom.
1:23). The design of nature, therefore, is a two-edged sword. On one hand, it is general revelation to
all men everywhere of the character of God as Creator and Sustainer. On the other hand, its
brightness causes the rebellious to shut their eyes and drives them to idolatry. Man's response to
nature's design shapes the quality of his dominion to which I now turn.
EVIL IN NATURE Evil permeates both sides of the man-nature distinction. When Adam fell, God
cursed the ground because of his sin, a fact crucial to Paul's exposition of the resurrection hope in
Romans 8:18-23. Evil damaged nature as it did man. Sin-Damage to Nature's Design While it is still
true after the fall that nature reveals its Creator, it is also true that much chaos has come into the
message. Nature has become abnormal. There is now natural evil: storms, earthquakes, plagues,
and famine. Nature even pollutes itself! Gases and vapors from natural decay pollute the
atmosphere. A classic example is the Los Angeles basin. Long before the automobile and white
man's industrialization, native American Indians referred to the area as "the place of the burning
eyes". It seems that trees growing in the basin area secreted a volatile organic compound that
strongly irritated human tissue. Paganism interprets such natural evil as a normal occurrence. The
pagan mind cannot imagine nature without evil in it. Evil has always been and will always be. Thus
evolutionary theory relies on natural evil (struggle for survival) to bring forth life. That, says the
pagan, is the message of nature. Once this "revelation" is accepted, a counterfeit moral code quickly
arises. For example, Sir Arthur Keith, a British anthropologist who had just survived Hitler's bombing
of Britain could write these amazing words in 1947: "To see evolutionary. . .morality being applied to
the affairs of a great nation we must turn to Germany of 1942. We see Hitler devoutly convinced that
evolution produces the only real basis for a national policy."[13] American business tycoon John D.
Rockefeller made the same inference: "The growth of large business is merely survival of the fittest.
. . .This is not an evil tendency in business. It is merely the working out of a law of nature."[14] Sin-
damage to nature confuses the creation message in many of its parts. Chaos and apparently
useless features appear in enough places that Christians' argument-from-design (teleological
argument for existence of God) is difficult to state precisely. Nature is not normal, and therefore
does not perfectly reveal God's original workmanship. [15] Sin-Damage to Man's Rule over Nature
You saw above that sin damaged man's first divine institution of responsible dominion both in its
extent and in its quality. Let's look further at this damage. Strangely, the cursing of nature has had
some beneficial results for man in his falleness. We are forced to work together to produce whether
Lesson 17 Part II __________________________________________________________________ Page 63 Bible
Framework Ministries www.bibleframework.org we like it or not. A number of other effects also
follow. North makes very insightful observations: "There are no free lunches in a cursed, scarce
world. . . .Given the perverse nature of man, a less productive world is a necessity. Having to work is.
. .a way of draining energy that might have been put to perverse ends. Men have less free time to
scheme and pillage. They have less strength. . . .An expenditure of time, capital, and energy in
increasing the productivity of the land could not be used simultaneously in order to commit murder
and mayhem. . . .The curse of the ground is also a blessing for the ground. Men in a scarce world
must treat the creation with care if they wish to retain the productivity of the ground.[16] Again the
pagan mind can't interpret the situation correctly. Thinking evil has always been part of existence;
the carnal mentality sees labor as inherently toilsome with no higher calling. From ancient Greece to
many in America's present labor force, work (especially "blue collar" work) is treated with derision
and avoidance where possible. The biblical Christian, on the other hand, knows that labor was the
first occupation of God and of man. A creative person cannot help but labor over nature to produce
worthwhile fruit. He knows that the thorns and thistles in every job are not what labor is all about.
They are merely abnormalities added because of sin. Later in this series I will show how the spiritual
life closely parallels physical labor. We struggle with that part of nature closest to us–our flesh–to
bring it into subjection under Christ that His fruit, and not thorns and thistles, might be produced.
Sadly, Christians often drift into pagan modes of thought, looking for some "secret" that will subdue
the flesh without labor (note God's words to Cain in Gen. 4:7).
Our website has a team of professional writers who can help you write any of your homework. They will write your papers from scratch. We also have a team of editors just to make sure all papers are of HIGH QUALITY & PLAGIARISM FREE. To make an Order you only need to click Ask A Question and we will direct you to our Order Page at WriteDemy. Then fill Our Order Form with all your assignment instructions. Select your deadline and pay for your paper. You will get it few hours before your set deadline.
Fill in all the assignment paper details that are required in the order form with the standard information being the page count, deadline, academic level and type of paper. It is advisable to have this information at hand so that you can quickly fill in the necessary information needed in the form for the essay writer to be immediately assigned to your writing project. Make payment for the custom essay order to enable us to assign a suitable writer to your order. Payments are made through Paypal on a secured billing page. Finally, sit back and relax.
About Wridemy
We are a professional paper writing website. If you have searched a question and bumped into our website just know you are in the right place to get help in your coursework. We offer HIGH QUALITY & PLAGIARISM FREE Papers.
How It Works
To make an Order you only need to click on “Order Now” and we will direct you to our Order Page. Fill Our Order Form with all your assignment instructions. Select your deadline and pay for your paper. You will get it few hours before your set deadline.
Are there Discounts?
All new clients are eligible for 20% off in their first Order. Our payment method is safe and secure.